Statements

SRL Files Amicus Brief Defending the Integrity of Social Security Data

September 18, 2026

The Society for the Rule of Law has filed an amicus brief in U.S. Department of Homeland Security, et al., v. League Women Voters, et al., urging the Supreme Court to uphold the U.S. District Court of D.C.’s decision to vacate the modified SAVE system. The modified SAVE system enables DHS to repurpose Social Security data to verify a voter’s immigration status. This is not the intended use of Social Security data, and DHS’s use thus violates the Privacy Act of 1974.

The brief argues that the modified SAVE system must be vacated because the Government fails to demonstrate how its purpose of disclosing Social Security data to the Dept. of Homeland Security is compatible with the original purpose of collecting the data—a core component of the Privacy Act.

Congress enacted the Privacy Act in anticipation of today’s digital age and the ease by which governments could assemble massive amounts of data on Americans. Wary of the risks of mass data collection, Congress wrote into the act substantive and procedural requirements meant to safeguard Americans’ fundamental rights to privacy.

The amicus brief describes how the substantive requirements of the Privacy Act require clear congruence between Congress’s original purpose in collecting data and an administrative agency’s modern use of that data. As our brief details, this compatibility test reflects Congress’s decision to prevent the government from accumulating “so much information about a person that that person could no longer maintain a realistic sense of privacy.” Britt v. Naval Investigative Serv., 886 F.2d 544, 550 (3d Cir. 1989).

In addition to the substantive requirements, the brief also shows how the modified Save database violates the Privacy Act’s procedural rules. These rules include a mandatory period for public comments and criticism before administrative agencies use private data in new ways—but the Administration’s SAVE system would go forward without following this process.

Honoring this procedural standard reinforces the core rule of law principle that federal agencies must execute the law as written and in accordance with Congress’s original design, instead of kowtowing to the shifting priorities of successive administrations.

The Privacy Act of 1974 was enacted to address concerns that the federal government’s growing capacity to collect, store, and disseminate personal information posed a serious threat to individual privacy.

A key component of the Privacy Act is a simple but powerful principle: personal records collected by a federal agency for one purpose may not be disclosed for an incompatible purpose. The Privacy Act permits disclosure for a “routine use,” but only when that use is “compatible with the purpose for which [the record] was collected.” 5 U.S.C. § 552a(a)(7).

To ensure that a federal agency’s disclosure is compatible for a routine use, the government must show that there is a genuine nexus between the purpose of collection and the purpose of disclosure to another federal agency. As the Third Circuit put it, the statutory requirement of compatibility requires “a dual inquiry into the purpose for the collection of the record in the specific case and the purpose of the disclosure.” Britt v. Naval Investigative Serv., 886 F.2d 544, 548 (3d Cir. 1989). Compatibility is the “meaningful degree of convergence” between the two purposes, not mere relevance or utility for such disclosure. Id. at 549.

In its Application for Stay, the government fails to demonstrate that the Social Security Administration’s purpose in collecting the social security data is compatible with the purpose in disclosing it to the Department of Homeland Security. Instead, the government focuses on the ubiquity of Social Security numbers as identifiers. This does not meet the compatible analysis. The risk to individual privacy will be magnified if the government is permitted to disregard the compatible analysis.

Read our full amicus brief here. For press inquiries, please contact [email protected].

 

# # #